How to Lower Home Insurance and Keep Coverage | Be Wealthy

Home/Podcast/Episode 64

Episode 64 Nov 18, 2026 45 min

12 Home Insurance Rules That Saved Me $9,509 a Year

Brett Tanner's cabin insurance went from almost $11,000 to a $16,423 renewal in three years, with zero claims. He shopped every policy he owns line by line and saved $9,509 a year (38%) while getting better coverage. He and Katelyn Mitchell walk through the 12 rules he used, starting with insuring the disaster instead of the small stuff.

Brett TannerBrett TannerHost, founder of Be WealthyKatelyn MitchellKatelyn MitchellCo-host, runs operations for Brett
Watch it here, or listen wherever you get podcasts.Open on YouTube
  1. Insure the disaster and pay small losses yourself

    Brett's number one rule is "insure severity, not frequency." A $4,000 water leak, a stolen bike or a broken window is a check most people can write, and filing small claims pushes premiums up. Save your insurance for the house burning down or a big liability claim you could never cover yourself.

    Jump to 8:14
  2. Raise the deductible until the savings stop

    Brett runs a $25,000 deductible on his primary home because he has cash set aside to cover it, and going from $10,000 to $25,000 made sense. Going from $25,000 to $50,000 would have saved only $161 to $271 a year for $25,000 more risk, so he said no. Have your broker quote several deductible levels and see where the savings stop.

    Jump to 12:16
  3. Insure what it costs to rebuild today

    For insurance, the only number that matters is what it costs to rebuild what you have today. A family friend's mountain cabin burned down after an overfilled propane tank exploded in the garage. The replacement coverage wasn't enough, and they paid a lot out of pocket. Ask for guaranteed replacement if a carrier offers it.

    Jump to 16:25
  4. Compare every policy spec line by line

    Two quotes on the same house are almost never the same coverage, and the cheap one is usually just thinner. Brett uploads the full declaration pages to an AI tool and has it compare dwelling amount, deductible, liability limit, contents, water backup, umbrella and every endorsement side by side. Katelyn ran the same process on their business insurance and checked every policy against their loan documents for gaps.

    Jump to 18:31
  5. Never tell a new agent what you pay now

    If you say you pay $3,800 a year, the agent only has to beat it by about $100 to win you. Brett hands over the specs and asks what they would do in his place. He also gives them every detail he can, like a new roof or brand new water heaters, because newer systems can lower the price.

    Jump to 21:37
  6. The best setup may use more than one carrier

    Moving everything to one carrier would have saved Brett about $5,000 a year. Moving only the cabin, to the carrier with the better product for that house, saved $9,509. His primary home and his cars stayed where they were. If you split carriers, tell your umbrella carrier who holds each policy underneath it.

    Jump to 22:38
  7. Read every endorsement on every dec page

    Brett found $333 a year for two umbrella endorsements that cannot pay a claim involving a car he owns. He got back about $1,300 lost to a wrong cancellation date and caught one house listed twice on a dec page. He dropped rental car coverage because he has other cars, but he keeps glass coverage.

    Jump to 28:50
Raising a deductible is free money right until it isn't and nobody tells you where the line is because nobody runs a comparison.
Brett Tanner  ·  at 13:18
By the numbers

What changed when Brett shopped his policies

The numbers Brett shared from his own renewal, all with zero claims filed.

What he checkedBeforeAfter
Cabin premiumAlmost $11,000 three years ago, $13,586 last year, $16,423 proposed at renewal$6,900 a year
Cabin rebuild coverageUp to $2 millionGuaranteed replacement up to $5 million
How he split carriersOption of moving everything to one carrier: about $5,000 a year savedMoved only the cabin: $9,509 a year saved (38%)
Primary home deductible$25,000Quote for $50,000 saved only $161 to $271 a year, so he kept $25,000
Umbrella endorsements$333 a year for two that cannot pay a claim involving a car he ownsRemoved
Wrong cancellation date$1,305 lost on a policy he had canceledMoney recovered
Chapters

Skip to the part you need.

Tap any chapter and the video starts right there.

“Two quotes of the same house are almost never the same coverage. So the cheap one usually isn't cheap, it's just thinner.”

Brett Tanner at 20:33
  1. Intro
  2. Why Premiums Keep Rising
  3. Insure Severity, Not Frequency
  4. Picking Your Deductible
  5. Liability and Umbrella Coverage
  6. How I Shopped My Policies
  7. One Carrier or Several
  8. $16,423 Down to $6,900
  9. Four Things I Found
  10. The 12-Rule Playbook
  11. The 90-Minute Review
Free tool

Insurance Audit

Put every policy you pay for in one place and check it for the same red flags Brett found, like the $333 a year of umbrella endorsements that cannot pay a claim involving a car he owns.

Try it free

Mentioned in this episode

BookThe Be Wealthy AI program Katelyn and I talk about. Book a quick call to see how it works: bewealthypodcast.com/ai
Questions

From this episode.

How can I lower my home insurance without cutting coverage?

Brett shops every policy once a year with a broker who quotes many carriers, and he compares the actual specs line by line. He also raises deductibles to the point where the savings stop. His cabin renewal came in at $16,423, and he moved it to a $6,900 policy that added guaranteed replacement up to $5 million.

Why is my home insurance going up when I haven't filed a claim?

Brett points to three causes. Carriers pay more for their own insurance (reinsurance) after wildfires and hurricanes, rebuild costs have climbed with inflation, and carriers price in risk for whole areas like wildfire zones and hail markets. His cabin went from almost $11,000 to $16,423 in three years with no claims and no changes to the house.

Should I raise my homeowners insurance deductible?

Only if you have the cash set aside to pay it, and only up to the point where the savings stop. Compare the extra risk to what you save each year and how many years it takes to earn it back. Brett's move from $10,000 to $25,000 made sense, but going to $50,000 would have saved only $161 to $271 a year.

How do I switch home insurance without a gap in coverage?

Keep the old policy in force until the new carrier's underwriting has cleared you in writing. Then line up both policies to start and end on the same day. Brett warns that a gap or a non-renewal on your record makes you harder to insure, so if you get a non-renewal letter, start shopping right away.

Should I self-insure or set up a captive insurance company?

Brett says it rarely makes sense unless you pay $500,000 or more a year in premiums. A private coaching client with 80 renewals wanted to self-insure, but most of his houses cost $700 to $1,300 a year to insure. Brett told him it wasn't worth taking on a $400,000 risk to save that.

Read the full transcript8,777 words · about 38 minutes to read

0:00insurance went up 53%. Isn't that awesome? We started this podcast telling us it was 10 grand and now you're all the way down to 6,900. I'm here in DFW and it's absolutely the hail capital. And the impact with our insurance has been insane. Having your insurance sucks. Can I just say it? It sucks. It's not fun. The whole thing sucks. But now today, it's easier, right? You've got to show us how you did this. Welcome back to the Be Wealthy podcast. I'm here joined by Katelyn, who I never see because she lives in another state. However, I just started for four or five straight days at our mastermind, which was excellent. And Katelyn today, not the sexiest topic ever, we're gonna talk about insurance. And the reason we're gonna talk about it, because my insurance went up 53%. Isn't that awesome? 53% increase. And by the way, I've had no claims. So I want to put a zero claims. 53% increase and I don't think I'm the only one. I was about to say, I would guarantee you if we

1:03pulled everyone listening to the podcast right now, everyone's insurance is going up. We own with our partner a property and casualty insurance and every one of those policies is consistently going up. Like this could not be a more timely topic for us. I'm excited about it. Full disclosure, Katelyn and I actually own a property and casualty business and this stuff still shocks us. So first, if you are not shopping your insurance with a broker, every single year, one time per year at a bare minimum, I know one thing Katelyn about you. I know like you're on that squat rack right now. You're on the stair machine. I know something about you. You're overpaying for your insurance and you could save a lot of money. The problem is we don't wanna just, we don't wanna cut insurance coverage to save money. We want ideally the ultimate coverage, the optimal coverage for the least amount of money is always the game we're playing, right? It's not being cheap for cheap's sake. It's can I get the most for the least, right? That's what we should be obsessed with. So

2:04Katelyn, this is my cabin in the mountains. This is the one that got me. So I'm in like an area where technically we could have wildfires, which even makes it more complicated. So three years ago, Katelyn, I was paying almost 11 grand a year, $11,000 a year. Last year jumps to $13,586. So that's a 30, whatever percent increase. This year's renewal, again, no claims the entire period. Now it's at $16,423. So 10 bucks beats me, right? So nothing changed with the house. Katelyn didn't become more complicated. Okay, there's been no additions. There's been no new things added. It's been identical in every way, but here we're gonna get to why that occurs. And I'm gonna do you what I did to save a bunch of money. So the first thing we gotta do, right, is we've got to compare like kind. We gotta make sure we're comparing as they would say apples to apples, right? The coverage, we cannot do actual cash value,

3:04which would mean it burns down to get a check. As opposed to replacement costs, we're gonna rebuild the actual asset. And so all said here, my personal insurance at the end of the result that I'm about to share with you, I saved almost $10,000 per year. Katelyn, that's not even the cool part. Not my coverage got better. Not worse coverage, better coverage for way less money and I saved $10,000. $9,509, Katelyn, to be exact, which was a savings of 38. You've gotta show us how you did this. 38%. So it's a big deal. And I just want everybody to know that. We mentioned that we own an insurance business. We are not here to sell your insurance. We're here to sell you on you. So the first thing you gotta understand about insurance, if you shop it with one carrier, you have one chance to save money, right? I'm not against state farm. I'm not against farmers. That isn't my comment, but they sell one product line that may or may not be the lowest insurance. And the things they crush at be great that you should stay there.

4:07But you may need multiple carriers today. I think, Katelyn, that's the myth. Number one, you gotta be open to multiple carriers. And the odds are the person that shops it with the most carriers has the most potential to save you money. And it's not what people think about. So, Katelyn, here's where we're gonna go. Why is insurance skyrocketing? I went into the research because again, I happen to own an insurance business, but I don't spend my day-to-day running an insurance business. The first thing is the carriers, believe it or not, they also have insurance. It's called reinsurance. So you're insuring Katelyn with whatever, met life or whoever. They're also buying reinsurance. Well, do you think the reinsurance costs have gone up or down? And before you answer that, we had a little wildfire issue out in California. We've got, storms are hitting differently later. You had that flooded- Hurricane's in Florida. Hurricanes are just in Florida. So you've got all these things, Kauai just got destroyed. And so, the beach house where I, again, as a reverend, as a man of the cloth, where I

5:09married people, like the section where they got married like doesn't actually exist, right? It's crazy. So reinsurance, because of that Katelyn, the reinsurance goes up. Well, where does that go? Well, it just flows right to you, right? If their costs go up 26%, the insurance company cannot eat that, right? So they're gonna pass along the reinsurance to you. Second issue that's driving up your insurance premiums. Katelyn, the rebuild costs have costs gone up over the last three or four years as inflation continues to go on. Exponentially. Well, so if you have replacement coverage, they're rebuilding your home. So as costs go up, we're gonna pay more money to rebuild our home. Where does that come? It shows up in your premium. That's how they do it. Next thing is carriers are treating from whole categories of risk. So now if you're in one of those areas where they deem it just, we're gonna slap the button down here and stamp it on a table called risk. Katelyn, if you're near a wildfire, there has never been one knock on what anywhere near my cabin, like within

6:12immediate radius. Yet we're in these super tall pine trees and the carriers are scared of it, right? Cause if it comes in there, it's just gonna ravage everything. So they're gonna say, hey, we got to price in the potential risk, even though we haven't had any. Like if you're like in a coastal wind area or I don't even know what a hail belt is, but you're in certain markets, Katelyn, like where like hurricanes hit, they're just gonna go, look, we got hit over here, wasn't near you. We're just gonna price that into everything we're doing in your area of price in the future. I'm here in DFW and it's absolutely the hail capital and the impact with our insurance has been insane. And the other thing, Katelyn, you might have like a state backed fallback plan, some states don't have it, but those are the primary reasons why you're seeing it go up so much. And so the consequence nobody tells you, a non-renewal on your record makes you harder to insure everybody else and everyone should think about that. If you non-renew, like if you skip it,

7:13you have like a gap in coverage and everybody say it, what is the other carrier thing? Well, why does Katelyn have a gap? Well, she's got a gap because she had an issue or they dropped her or whatever, right? And so you just need to make sure like you do not want gaps in coverage, okay? So the worst possible strategies, it sits still, carrier drops you and then you go shopping as a distressed buyer. Oh my gosh, I don't have insurance right now. Like, so if you get a letter saying, hey, we're not gonna renew your coverage, you gotta start right now to get on that. If you need help in your business right now, you've got to challenge or an opportunity that you really want to hone in and capitalize on it and make a game-changing breakthrough in your business. Come out to our one-day workshop. This is something we've never done before. We're now doing them at the resorts we've bought, so they could be at Apple Mountain, Georgia. They could be in Northern Arizona. They might even be in Belize in the future, but you get to come to a one-day where they're, I'm not going to present slides. It's literally you and your business and you're going to leave with an action plan you can implement in your business. Go to

8:14bewealthypodcast.com and you can click on our upcoming events and see where we'll be and book to come. The room is limited. We have no more than 15 people in the room. Go to bewealthypodcast.com and you can book our one-day workshop coming up. So there's one principle that saves the most money. Katelyn, if you get one thing out of this, if our listeners of yours get one thing out of it, is you insure severity, not frequency. What do you mean by that? So most people focus on frequency, small stuff. Little thing breaks, I got a water leak over here for three, four, five grand. I'm insuring against that, a $4,000 water leak, a stolen bike, a broken window, whatever, right? And so the truth is most people can write a check for that and if you can't, let's solve that a different way because today if you're filing claims all the time, you're really not gonna like your premiums. You saw what mine did with no claims, right? We've gotta file severity claims, right? The whole house burns down, that's

9:16why we're doing it. We can't self-fund those. So I wanna have people think about the things that you could self-fund that are smaller and you check with your insurance agent, utilize AI, which we're gonna talk a lot about that here today on here to help solve this. That was how I was able to solve it and compare apples to apples and read all the documents and make sure I was comparing correctly. But we've gotta insure severity, not frequency. So major things, Katelyn, we can't self-fund, catastrophic loss, mass liability, house burning down. It's the disaster, right? What would constitute a disaster? Does your insurance cover those things? By the way, if you're in a severity area, like a hurricane area, you need to get the coverage for the thing that severity could cause, right? There is coverage for most things. You just may not like the price. Frequency are the small little things we need to think about. And so as it relates to frequency, the first place we gotta start talking, Katelyn, is about your deductible. So I run the highest deductible that makes cognitive sense. Here's what I mean by that. If I increase my

10:16deductible, say, from $1,000 to 2,500, Katelyn, what I'm going to do is measure what is my savings in premium and how many years are gonna need to go by to make that up without a claim? Now, in my particular situation, I'm not gonna file a claim for 1,000 or 2,500. Even if you have a $4,000 claim, I think people realize this, but forget, if you have a $4,000 claim, Katelyn, your deductible's $2,500, you're only gonna get a check for 1,500 bucks. And then if next year your premium goes up by 2,500, this wasn't a great trade in the business, right? Do you have a ratio that you look at, Brett? So when you say, hey, if I can get, if I can increase for, she's an example, let's say I can increase my deductible from a $10,000 deductible to a $25,000 deductible. So it's gonna be $15,000 more in a deductible. How many years of savings on premium? Like what is that ratio for you? Is it, you

11:16know, hey, it's gotta pay back in four years. It's gotta pay back in two years. Well, anything that's like, I think there's a two-part answer to that question, which is one, where are you going to file a claim? I didn't get to start there. Like for me, with the volume and size of our policies, and so a claim, that's gonna get reported everywhere. And if that raises our insurance premiums by 5% across the board, it's a disaster for you and I, just in addition to everything else. So the number one, where would you file? Number two, if you could see like, hey, as long as I don't have claims for five years, this is actually a great decision for me. I made money to do it. So like I've literally never had not going to a catastrophic loss on my primary or my cabin. I have had a catastrophic loss on a rental property. I had something burned to the ground, rubble insurance that everything was supposed to do. So I run $25,000 deductibles on my primary residence because it makes economic sense for me, Katelyn, to

12:16take that risk because I've got the assets put away somewhere else where doomsday I can afford the $25,000 problem and then I'm insuring the severity. So I look at that. The analysis, so here's where you go, Katelyn. If you check, now I looked on my policy, and here's a live example. If I was to go from $25,000 to $50,000 deductible, is it worth it? It's saved between $161 and $271 a year. That's a long way to recoup that. That doesn't really make sense, right? So it's like, I mean, I would be taking on $25,000 of more risk to save a few hundred bucks. I declined that one, but it actually the math leading into that from 10 to 25 actually made sense, right? So you gotta know the skill we're talking about here that you wanna develop in all things, right? It's the same answer I would give you should you pay points on a refinance. How long are you gonna have the home and how much does it save you and when do you get your money back? You give me those three

13:18variables, I would tell you what to do. And so the actual skill is knowing where the savings stop. Raising a deductible is free money right until it isn't and nobody tells you where the line is because nobody runs a comparison. So everyone watching this is gonna have your, when you quote your insurance, you're gonna leave this call, you're gonna go quote it with a broker that shops it everywhere and ask them to compare. Hey, compare all the deductibles in your comfort zone. $1,000, $2,000, $5,000, $10,000, $15,000, $20,000, whatever that is and to see where it makes sense. And your agent should guide you to do that. You know, there's one more thing to check by name. Some carry a large loss deductible waiver. Katelyn, that's built into your policy. Some carries, it's almost like a way they sell it. And so if you have that, the high deductible actually doesn't cost you anything if the losses actually matter. So you might have like, so like you have a mass loss coming but it's like, hey, what they're trying to avoid is the like insurance carriers don't want the small claims. They don't want you just filing a claim for your grill kind of got a little hot and lit the side of the countertop on fire

14:20and melted a bunch of stuff, right? Hypothetically. Hypothetically never happened to me. But if that happened, like you wouldn't want to file a claim on it. They want like, they know that like you're gonna file house burns to the ground. Katelyn's gonna file insurance claim. And so you took a high deductible. If it's a total loss, you don't have the high deductible. Meaning they're gonna just, they're gonna lower that down. Now, if you file a $100,000 claim and they're gonna still charge you the $25,000 deductible, right? So they're kind of moving it into, it's another way of them saying, hey, we're gonna insure the catastrophic things that we could save you money, but you're taking a little bit of the risk on the smaller claims. Makes sense? Makes total sense. So now you got the same idea but you got it in reverse. Here's where I spend more money, not less. So once we've got that coverage, Katelyn, I always look at what are my liability coverages and what are my umbrellas? I carry personally, right? Now, mind you, as an individual, as a human being, Brett Tanner the Human owns very little things,

15:24right? Everything I owns by an entity and a trust and these other structures that have moved things away from me, right? That I own them, they're owned somewhere else. I have access to them or controls that are baked into those agreements. So a $10 million personal umbrella covers my son, you know, who's an 18-year-old driver which is terrifying in and of itself. My daughter's about to be 16 and so she'll be driving. So those are gonna be personal coverages and so I want to be fully covered on those things, right? So you would think about liability and umbrella. Katelyn, I'm gonna go out high. I wanna really look at that because that's where your risks come in, right? Those once in, hopefully never events that just happen from something that can be a liability exposure. So full replacement cost on the dwelling. This is where I overspend. Like I wanna know that if something happens, I've got full replacement cost and so it's not market value. I don't really care about the market value. I wanna know what it actually costs to rebuild

16:25and ideally, Katelyn, you wanna get a guaranteed replacement provision if you can. What is a guaranteed replacement provision? What does that mean? Some carriers offer it, meaning like we guarantee to replace it, like no matter like something almost like I think it's their marketing plan that's really baked into their documents. The other ones, right? They may have you a cost for replacement. Hey, as long as Katelyn, your replacement is X, $500,000, you're good to go. Well, Katelyn goes in there and starts rebuilding and finds out, I can't rebuild what I have in the way I had it. I could rebuild a much cheaper version that I don't want but it didn't replace what I actually have. So knowing what things cost today and the insurance carriers have models for this, the danger we all have, Katelyn, is we stay with a single carrier. You insured your house for say $500,000 and let's use it 10 years ago in Phoenix, Arizona and over the last 10 years, it skyrocketed in value and your replacement costs only went up incrementally. So now, and but your build costs went up triple.

17:30So now I have a claim and my price to rebuild doesn't equal what it costs me to rebuild today if you don't have it connected. You've actually seen people completely harmed by this. Can you be sure to story with me? This is a huge issue. Yeah, I've got a family friend who had a beautiful cabin in the mountains. Everything was great and they went and filled up a propane tank one day and it was through not one of those exchange places is one where they actually fill it, they overfilled it. So the tanks rattling around in the back of the truck, they drive home, park the truck in the garage, they leave to go to dinner. Whatever reason that tank explodes, kaboom, house burns to the ground. And the insurance company, the replacement cost wasn't enough to replace it. So they got it. Everyone was safe though. Everyone was safe. That's the beauty of the story. The negative is it didn't replace as they had to come out of pocket for a bunch of money and it created stress and pressure where none was needed. And now you could magnify that. What if you didn't have the money, right? Now it's, now I've got a half

18:31built home and it sucks. So just taking the time to do this and make sure the big question you're asking with insurance, would my policy do what I expect it to in the unlikely event I have a catastrophic loss? And if you, long as you could answer that for yourself, not what an insurance person told you, but what's backed up by the documents you actually have, you're in a great place. It's been said that the breakthrough in your life is gonna come from a person, an idea, maybe a strategy. And I believe that every person has one breakthrough from just changing their entire life. I want you to come spend one day with me, in my office with no more than 15 business owners, bring your biggest challenge, your biggest opportunity and let's solve that so you get what you want and you don't end up with a career that doesn't land where you want at the end, go to bewealthypodcast.com. All right, so Katelyn, what did I do? How did I actually do this? You cannot compare quotes and insurance. You cannot, because Katelyn, the quotes are gonna quote different things, right? What looks like it's better in one case may actually be costly in another. So what we're comparing is

19:33specs in the policy. So number one, this is where AI can help you immensely, you upload two full deck pages with all the pay, and you go, hey, give me a full comparison on all coverage line by line, A versus B, give me cost coverage, deductible, liability, everything in there. Like from the, and I'm talking dwelling amount, deductible, liability limit, contents, water backup, umbrella, what is the umbrella count? The exact endorsements that are in your policy, right? We gotta compare apples and apples. That's the only way you get it. And you're gonna find that no carrier has the exact same things, right? This one's got three extra features I like, but I lost two things that I wanted. And this one's got some awesome stuff, but there's one thing in here that just totally sucks, right? So you're kind of picking it together and figuring out, can I get where I wanna go at a cost that makes sense. Now, before we do this, Katelyn, I'll tell you the way you can easily overpay for everything you don't need. Insurance is a game that's

20:33limitless, right? You can, as you and I know in our business, you can overpay, and if you insure against everything, you won't have any money. So you're going to take, you go out of business and you cannot insure against everything. So you gotta be careful there. So every carrier got the same identical specs. Here's what I want. Shop it comes back, we're comparing those together. AI can beautifully put this in a spreadsheet for you and help you do the comparison. The part that everybody gets wrong, two quotes of the same house are almost never the same coverage. So the cheap one usually isn't cheap, it's just thinner. You're just getting less coverage. So your coverage is thinner. That's what can happen, right? And so never shop on the lowest replacement cost. What people default on insurance is I'm shopping for what's cheapest. And like all things in life, Katelyn, what's cheapest is rarely best, right? What we want to know is the way you have your home today, just to rebuild it in its current state so you would have exactly what you have, we gotta know that number so we can insure for that.

21:37Next, Katelyn, when you're shopping at insurance, don't tell them the price. Some people go to them like, oh, here's my dec pages, here's what I'm currently paying, can you beat it? Well, they could play around the, I want them to come in and try to crush it and save all the money possible. I also want, when I'm talking to someone, I already know everything that I know and I know what my current insurance person knows. What I don't know is what the two other people I'm talking about this now, right? So I want experts coming in and giving me advice on my policy that I may not know it's how you get more educated. And you've seen me do this, Katelyn, again and again, I come into everything knowing nothing. Hey, look, I know what I have. I think I know why I have it. What would you do if you were me? What's a better way to insure this that I'm not thinking about? How were you thinking about maximizing coverage and lowering my expenses? And so I just, I never show my hand, right? Here's the specs that I need. And there's a lot of data you need. When did you replace your roof? And what's the electrical and you're gonna, the more data, by the way, you give them the better the coverage you can get. If you say, what age are your hot water heaters? Well, I don't know, I don't care. Well, unless I

22:38say, hey, three of them are brand new, right? If you've got a new roof, Katelyn, you can save money on your coverage. So letting them know matters. And again, AI is a wonderful tool that can help you do it. So now, once we've structured it, so my first instinct was, hey, I'm gonna move everything to one carrier because that'll be easier. Katelyn, by moving it to one, it's easier to manage, just move it all. Had I done that, I would have saved five grand a year, which is kind of cool, but I was able to save 9,500. So moving it all wasn't the decision. So I moved one house because this carrier had a better product for that house, right? And I left the rest where it was. And so sometimes there's multi-policy discounts because I had more than one policy there, I was able to get a discount. But if I moved all of them over this, when I moved the second house, this other carrier, it was more expensive. I didn't save as much money. So you're really optimizing for both cost and coverage as you go. Brett, are there any concerns in having

23:43coverage with multiple carriers, meaning let's go on your personal side, right? You have the umbrella, which covers you personally. And then you have two individual policies for your primary residences. And you have your son. I'm like, how do all of those layer if they're not all with the same carrier? A few of our clients have asked me that in the past. So I know there'll be people on this podcast that'll be curious as well. Totally. And an umbrella, using that as an example, right? You're gonna have to let the umbrella company know who your initial coverage is to make sure that it meets the criteria. So when you move it to multiple places, you've just gotta make sure, essentially, that we're all talking together. If we've got an umbrella, just like an umbrella that goes in the rain that covers or no rain gets on me, the umbrella goes over all of your personal assets, I've gotta have communication with the umbrella to connect those assets to said umbrella. So let me know. So when you have multiple carriers, there's a little bit of coordination that's not obvious, but I

24:43would not argue that it's overly cumbersome, especially when the savings can be $5,000 per year forever. It represents a lot of money. So here is what was interesting when I went side by side. So my cabin in the mountains is gonna sound insane. The proposed amount was $16,400 for renewal, and I got it done for $6,900. How is that even possible? That's less than it was the two years ago. You started this podcast telling us it was 10 grand, and now you're all the way down to 6,900? It went 10, 13, 16, six? That's not even the best part. I have a guaranteed replacement in my new policy, which I did not have before, okay? Before the cost to rebuild, they quoted it at $2 million, okay? I have a guaranteed replacement of up to five now. So not only am I paying exponentially less, I've got a better product

25:45for way less saving 38% every single year. And so- Nobody wants to do this. Shopping your insurance sucks. Can I just say it? It sucks. It's not fun. The whole thing sucks. But now today, it's easier, right? Because we're able to use AI to do it. If you were me, how would you go about, let's say you have a primary residence, you have an umbrella, and you have two cars? How would you go about looking at your insurance today and the process that you went through to get a result like what you did? First thing you do, you note at number one, go download all of your dec pages. Full policy that's got everything, the endorsements, what's covered, what's not. We gotta get all that together, okay? For all of your policies, all of them. I would utilize, you know, your favorite AI tool. We use Claude. We'll talk about that here in a minute. I would use all of that and I would have it build a spreadsheet that's gonna compare future coverage. What do I have now? It's gonna lay it all out. Katelyn, this column here, everything on your primary. Here's car one, here's car two, right? Here's

26:49the golf cart, whatever you've got. Here's my pet insurance, or whatever you've got that you currently have. All that's laid out. You will take just the, now you're gonna see like, am I covered? What is the rebuild cost? We're gonna do a little research. We're gonna take what we want and we're gonna shop that with a broker. We need to make sure that our broker is shopping with multiple carriers. You should ask your person, how many carriers do you actually shop at? Okay, so once we shop it, we can come back with information. We can make decisions based on what I'm about to go through here. So they've got it all laid out. They're at this point in the journey. You've got everything organized. Now we're gonna run through it. So when I lowered it, right? I wanna be precise about what happened and it's the counterintuitive part of it, okay? The old policy would have paid up to $2 million to rebuild. The new one guarantees up to five. So I don't have to pay as much attention to the replacement cost, right? Cause I know it's not gonna cost me $5 million to rebuild it, okay? Not only paying less money, Katelyn, I just know I'm covered, so I have less worry. So it's not a fluke. It's what happens when a

27:50policy sits around for years where the market moves around, that I talked about this earlier, right? The old policy, what happens? They're catching up, you know, the value skyrocketed and then we have this wildfire risk. So now my premium is up. And so my premium went up by, I mean, it's a crazy amount of money and they just keep, I mean, it's an infinite game. Even though, right, I'm not filing claims. So I would just tell you the, I didn't even care what I went with, I can share it here, I think it was Openly. So if you've got an expensive home Openly is where I ended up going and I loved a lot of the things they did. Now they weren't the best carrier, Katelyn, for my primary residence. That's why I had to keep it somewhere else. And so it's just interesting when you go like, well, why aren't they the best at that? I don't know why that is. Different risk profile, they're looking at it differently and it might be based on their customers, how much risk do we have in a certain area? You're also seeing today, certain carriers are buying other insurance carriers. And if they don't wanna be in that market, Katelyn, one way to do it is just raise

28:50prices until you leave. And so I believe that's what they're doing. Again, I'm not an insider in the insurance industry. But there's four things that I found, Katelyn, in my policies as I was researching it. And I bring these up because as people are analyzing this with AI, right, they need to know what I caught. So first I was paying $330 a year that was buying me absolutely nothing. I found two endorsements on my umbrella that cannot pay a claim involving a car that I own. So it's like, well, they were insuring me against these other things that I don't even like do. And that's how wasted insurance, we automatically added something in all those years ago. So I was paying $333 that wouldn't have covered me anyway. Now, that's not a huge one, but I guarantee people listening and watching this have things they're paying for that they don't know about. I had $1,305 that evaporated on a cancellation. So we went to cancel a policy, we missed some time, but you can go back, say, hey, I canceled this at a different date

29:55than what you're reflecting because insurance companies make mistakes. So I got that funds back. Meaning you had sold the property, you no longer owned it, yet you had continued to pay on the policy. You no longer had the property, though, that was being covered. So you went and showed them that it actually had transferred, there was no coverage at that time, and you were able to recoup the $1,300. Yeah, just make sure that you understand, hey, I had this coverage started this day. They might have had it insured another week or two. Well, hold on, why don't we line up the coverages on the same day? So then you've got another one here where they actually listed one of my houses twice on a dec page. So it wasn't actually a crazy cost, it was for some reason it was $1, but it's just fundamentally wrong, right? So again, I would not have been able to catch this without using some tool to say, hey, why is this on here? I emailed them and they're like, oh, we made a mistake. Well, I kind of don't want to miss, because when's that mistake going to show up, Katelyn?

30:57Randomly on an audit or when I have a catastrophic loss, they're like, hey, this isn't right, they're going to look, again, they're in the business of not paying out claims, so you got to look at it. And I can give you, I got two more examples. And so, Katelyn, when you look at this, do you know what you have? An auto is a wonderful place to look at it, right? Do you want glass coverage, do you have it? Are you going to rent a car? Do you need rental car coverage? Or do you not need it, right? There was a time in my life where if my car went out, I only have one car, rental car coverage is something I needed. Today, I got a couple cars, I don't, like I don't need rental car coverage, I'm going to use one of the other cars, so I'm not going to pay for that service that I don't need. Now I have to have glass coverage, because I do not know what my wife does, but she leaves the league and windshields broken on the freeway. I don't know what she's doing, I don't know if she just finds a gravel truck and gets right behind them and just sees how far she can drive, but she shatters. We're whipping through some windshields. I'm going to tell you, I cannot live without glass coverage. I'm going to tell you it's a huge thing,

31:58because I got to have it. Most of us make massive investments in our business, and some of those investments don't pay off. So you can come spend a day with me for $997. You come out to one of our resorts, you're gonna spend a day, bring your challenge, bring your opportunities, and let's work through it in a one-on-one coaching session. You're gonna be in a room of your peers, no more than 15 people are gonna be there, and I'm gonna coach you personally to tackle your challenge and your opportunity. Go to bewealthypodcast.com to see the next dates for our event. So here's the playbook, Katelyn. And here's the playbook everyone needs to follow. I'm going to go one by one. Number one, you need to insure severity, not frequency. High deductibles, huge liability limits, full replacement cost. Where insurance should be to insure major, major, major things, not small things. If you're not going to file the claim anyway, or it wouldn't make sense, ask your insurance agent. If I file a claim for $10,000, what might it do? And you could go use your AI tool to solve some of that. By the way, if you're thinking about AI or you're using AI like a Google search, I'm going to tell you you're behind.

33:01You're completely behind the game. Everything changed in terms of how tokens and how cheap it is to do incredible work about six months ago. And we watched people not doing it. I could tell you that AI has been transformational in my life. We have rolled out an AI product that shows you how we use it for things like this, how we use it in our companies, and how we're having our revenue and our companies grow where we're actually not even adding people. And we've never ran them better. If you want more information on our AI course, that will change everything for you when it comes to the guarantee that it'll save you five hours a week or give you your money back, click the link in the show notes, and we can set up a call to discuss it with you or get you all that information. So number one, Katelyn, insure severity, not frequency. Number two, raise the deductible until the savings stop. Do it until it makes sense. Again, provided you have money set aside and you can afford the additional deductible, you should raise it and compare where's the sweet spot to optimize to save money. You should look it on your car insurance, on your home, you should look at it. Number three, Katelyn, never create a gap

34:02or a lapse in your insurance. The old policy stays enforced until the new carrier's underwriting has cleared it in writing. Not a verbal, hey, we're good. You're all set, Katelyn. No, no, in writing, you're good to go and you're going to line them up to go out on the same day. Number four, never underinsure the dwelling. Insure the rebuild cost, not the market value. Market value is relevant for insurance purposes, right? It's something you and I look at. Katelyn, what's this thing worth? Who cares in insurance? All we care is whether it costs to rebuild what we already have, okay? Number five, you've got to figure out your actual specs you want to shop. Identify the specs that you want, and then you're going to compare the rate per thousand as a match deductible. So like, how much am I paying per thousand dollars of insurance is a good way to think about. All right, next, Katelyn. Number six, do not show them your hand and tell them I'm paying $3,800 a year. There's not a huge

35:04motivation to save you a lot more than 100 bucks, right? The goal of every insurance agent, again, is to save you money. What we want then is to save you the maximum amount of money, not just $1, so you switch. So don't show them your hand. Number seven, shop proactively on your schedule. I think this is an annual thing. As you know, Katelyn, I love doing it around the first of the year. I got all these things and these checklists that we teach in our Be Wealthy Mastermind. For me, this is a start of the year project, right? Unless the renewal comes in outside of the year, normally we go around January. We're going to just reshop everything that we've got to make sure we're getting the lowest rates or the max coverage that still makes sense for us. Number eight, look at different combinations. You may need multiple carriers. It may make sense for you to have one personally, but I gave the example. I've got my primary over here, I got my auto over there, and then I got my cabin over here, and that's what made the most sense for me. It's a little more complex, but for $10,000 a year, it's not that hard. It was a few extra hours of my

36:06time, not a huge deal. Read every endorsement. Katelyn, now you may not be reading the endorsements, but have your AI read it and take you right to this section and then have them walk you through it like a golden retriever. That's how I have my AI talk to me. I want to know what the endorsement, that's where I found the different charges that I was able to peel off. Like, well, what is this for? What is this actually covering? And again, if you upload all the other insurance policies you have, am I covered there already or do I actually need this? Okay, next thing, Katelyn, time discretionary moves to renewal dates. Okay, so don't like, you could kind of time this. Let's get it all together. Like, so we're not shopping 18 different times. It's really hard if your renewals are staggered on all of your things. Ideally, kind of all the insurance is coming due around the same time we're targeting renewal dates. If you hold property in an LLC or trust, verify the entity is named on the deck page. Katelyn, you and I know this, how many times in

37:06our mastermind do we see someone who has something in a LLC or trust and it's not named as an initial insured, it's not insured correctly in the name of it. Just throw in their personal name, slap some insurance on this. No, you've got to match ownership with insurance. And last one, and the one I won't, no captive insurance coming. Everybody for years come along, Katelyn, they get you to take on like personally, take on all this extra risk and you could self-assure and blah, blah, blah. Unless you've got $500,000 per year in annual premiums and really like a millions or more, looking at captive insurance and trying to drive down your insurance costs doesn't really make sense. Katelyn, I have a private coaching client, very wealthy guy, and he was like, look, I have these 80 renewals. I want to self-insure a lot of it, just take the risk on. I'm like, yeah, but on most of your houses, you're paying 700 bucks a year or $1300 a year. That risk is way too bad. You're going to take

38:06a $400,000 risk to lower that to, it just doesn't make sense. In most cases, the right insurance, relevant, relative to the rebuild cost, makes a ton of sense. So Katelyn, anything that we need to expand on there, I just gave that play about those 12 things that everyone needs to think about as they're shopping their insurance. Yeah, I actually do have something here. So you have these 12 steps, right? That's the playbook. Typically on these podcasts, we always leave you with actionable items that you can take to go implement into your life. And a lot of times, they're around mindset or methodology of something with your children or a way to think about your legacy or a way to evaluate your assets, right? This is one of the very few, and we're going to start doing more of these, that have a tactical approach of a checklist that you can go and do. And this project could take you, let's call it, seven hours to go through, read all your

39:08dec pages, do everything. If this was a year ago today, you would assign this to someone. It would take them a full day, if not a week, to do this project. And the really cool part is, I can speak to this from experience. You handled it in your own personal world and then gave me your playbook of how to utilize it inside of our AI system, inside of our exact overlay of our Claude and our VS Code. And you gave me your system in the form of what we'll call a directive. And you said, Katelyn, I modeled this directive after my personal insurance, and I'd like for you to go do it in our business insurance. Well, our business insurance has, God only knows how many policies it's an incredibly difficult project to take on. But because you had handed me the directive that you built, I was able to feed that to my AI machine, who I call Justine. She's quickly becoming one of my best friends. I gave it to Justine, and then I was

40:08able to go through and build exactly this. Create a spreadsheet with the dec pages, all of the deductibles, everything that I needed to know, such that I could go out and insure our insurance, ensure that we have the right policies, the right coverages, no gaps against our loan docs, everything that we needed was in place, and then drive down to have the best coverage that we needed at the lowest possible cost. And so I was able to work with our insurance companies to go out and achieve that. And I never would have been able to take something like that on if I did not have your directive along with our systems, right? Our actual AI, I think of it like a cake, right? All the pieces that we've built out. The cool part about this, this is going to be one of the tools that we give out in our AI training program where we give people the ability. Hey, here's how we did it. You can certainly

41:08listen to this podcast, grab these 12 things, go do it on your own by hand. Better than that would be grab these 12 things, type them into your ChatGPT or whatever you might be using to do the best that you possibly can with them. Or you can do what I did, guys. Just go ahead and say, hey, Brett, can you teach me how to use AI? And then can you also give me the exact directive on how to do this? And I would be remiss if I didn't say, man, going the faster way is a whole lot easier. Well, I think this podcast was incredible. I would prefer to have the cheat sheet. Well, and so I want to give, I think everyone, you mentioned seven hours, right? And that's what it would take, right? If you leverage AI, I think it'd be radically less. I think everyone can do this in 90 minutes. Okay, so I want to, I want to give them how they could do this in 90 minutes. So one, I want you to rip every declaration page you have, full policies. And we need to organize them in folders. So insurance for Katelyn, we got one for home, one for auto, one for umbrella, one for toys, one for rentals, one for business, okay? Different

42:09folders, every policy is going in. We're just throwing, we're just throwing docs in there. Name them, throw them in there, okay? Write down what you're actually paying for per policy per year. Break all that down, organize it where you've got every policy what you're paying. Most people have never seen it in one place, right? It's a much bigger number than we all think. But now we've got, so they're breaking it in a folder, the spreadsheet's all going to be one sheet showing everything, okay? Now you're going to find the frequent policy, the small writers, low deductibles, the item level coverage, and you're going to see what do I have that maybe I'm double paying for? Okay, look at opportunities here because they're all laid out together for the first time ever, most likely. Now, check your deductibles and quote three levels up. If you're at 1,000, quote 2005 and 10,000. If you're at 5,000, quote 10 and 20, right? And just see if the savings are real or not. Next, you check your liability limits and your umbrella height. Should you take more? This is the one place

43:09where I want to save you a bunch of money in one place. We may spend a little more because you're taking too much risk in another. So is your liability match for your needs? Does your umbrella high enough? An umbrella is the best coverage you could possibly have for what it does because it comes and sits above your current coverage. So if you have an issue, it covers you all the way up. Now, you're going to shop Katelyn at least three carriers. We've got to get at least three. I would want brokers. Now, by the way, you'd say, Brett, I'm going to go to one broker. They have all the carriers. Not every broker has every carrier. Some brokers may have these 38 carriers. This other broker may have these 21 that they don't have. And this other guy or girl may have four that no one has, right? And so AI can help you do it all. You can do all this in less than 90 minutes. For me, it's saved up to $10,000 per year. I know it'll work for you. It's one of the things that we've got to add to a checklist that we do every single year. It is something that is not complicated and it is a huge liability area that we can save you from. So thanks for sticking with

44:09us for the full time, Katelyn. Insurance is not the coolest topic. It's not sexy. But much like Justin Timberlake, maybe we bring the sexy part of insurance back. I think that's what we could do. We could bring the sexy part of insurance back. I'm a big Justin Timberlake fan. There's no question about it. I used to listen to that exact CD in my red Mustang as a teenage, elderly teenage gal at 18 or 19. And it was, I'm bringing sexy back. Yeah. That was my... Hi, Katelyn. I just wanted to see what you would say when I said that. That's why I did it. And that's Katelyn Mitchell who used to drive that Mustang with taking way too much risk. And she doesn't do that anymore because she's shopping. My deductible was way too high. Was way too high. I'm Brett Tanner. This is another episode of the Be Wealthy Podcast. We'll see you back here next week.

Keep listening

If this one helped.

Your next move

Bring your numbers to a day with Brett.

One day in the room with Brett on your real numbers. You leave with a 5-year plan.