Rental Property Calculator: Return On Equity | Be Wealthy

Home/Resources/SFR Reality Check

Free tool

Does Your Rental Actually Make Money?

Does your rental deserve your equity? One page. Ten minutes. No mercy.

Most landlords have never run their rental's real numbers. Not the ones you tell your friends, the real ones. Fill this out for your worst house first. Use last year's actual figures, not your best year's.

From the episode "Why Your Single Family Rentals May Suck", watch it →

Prefer paper? Download the worksheet and do it by hand.

Download the worksheet PDF
01

What's actually trapped in this house

AWhat the house would sell for today
$
BWhat you still owe on it
$
CSelling costs at ~7%
$

(agent + closing): A × 0.07. Auto-filled, edit if you know better.

D · Trapped Equity
A − B − C
$0

That number in D is capital. It doesn't know it lives in a house. It could work anywhere.

02

What the house really earns

Income (be honest):

EAnnual rent collected
$

Rent × 12 (at actual rent, not the Zillow dream).

FVacancy
−$

E × 0.06 (national vacancy is ~7% and climbing; use your real history if worse). Auto-filled, editable.

G · Real Collected Income
E − F
$0

Operating expenses (every line, no skipping):

Use last year's actual annual figures.

HProperty taxes
$
IInsurance
$

This year's renewal, the number that made you wince.

JProperty management
$

(≈10% of G) + leasing fee ÷ years between tenants.

KHOA dues
$
LRepairs & maintenance
$

12-month average, the little stuff.

MTurn cost ÷ years between tenants
$

Paint, floors, cleaning ≈ $2,000–4,000 per turn.

NCapex reserve
$

The big stuff WILL come: roof ≈ $30K/20yrs + HVAC ≈ $8K/15yrs + water heater ≈ $1.5K/10yrs ≈ $2,200/yr minimum.

O · Total Operating Expenses
H+I+J+K+L+M+N
$0
Monthly mortgage payment
$

Principal and interest. Leave at 0 if the house is paid off.

03

The three numbers that decide everything

1 · Your TRUE expense ratio O ÷ G
–
Under 35%you're operating like a REIT. (Check your math, even Invitation Homes barely holds 35, with in-house crews and program insurance.)
35–45%normal for a mom-and-pop rental. This is why your cashflow never matches the spreadsheet.
Over 45%the house works for your vendors, not for you.
2 · Your REAL annual cashflow G − O − (mortgage × 12)
–

Not what you hoped. What's left.

Return on Trapped Equity
Cashflow ÷ D
–

This is the only number that matters. Your equity could earn 8–12% in bigger, quieter assets. What is it earning trapped in this house?

04

The verdict

Above 8%Keep it. It earned its place.
4–8%Yellow. You're being paid something, but you're betting the rest on appreciation returning. That's a bet, not a plan.
Under 4%Your wealth is parked, not invested. Every year you wait costs you the spread.
NegativeYou don't own an investment. You own a savings account that calls you about plumbing.

Every figure this tool produces is a simplified estimate for education only, based on the numbers you enter. It is not financial, tax, or investment advice. Run real decisions past your own licensed advisors.

%

If it's mostly appreciation, understand that Phoenix home prices have been flat-to-down since June 2022, and rent growth is running ~3% while your costs run 5–7%. The engine that carried you isn't running.

The way out (without paying tax)

A Section 1031 exchange lets you move every dollar of that trapped equity into a bigger, quieter, higher-cashflow asset, multifamily, commercial, net-lease, and defer 100% of the tax. Your equity graduates. You stop paying retail for repairs on scattered doors and start operating at scale.

That's exactly what the next episode covers: where the equity goes.

Want the full 1031 breakdown now? Brett sat down with Michael Velasco, who runs 1031 exchanges for a living: listen to the episode.

Brett Tanner | The Be Wealthy Podcast

Prefer paper? Download the worksheet and do it by hand.

Download the worksheet PDF